"The most discouraging thing was the death threats," Russ said. WebWhile the DSK developments might be easier to swallow, given the dubious background and behavior of his accuser, Tuesdays Anthony verdict rocked the jurisprudential Although after he was born, Muybridge found a photo with Little Harry written on the back, so he didnt believe it was his. I have no idea what they talked about. Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more. I left with [just] the clothes on my back. Market data provided by Factset. But she was found guilty on four counts of providing false information to a law enforcement officer. Six years later Casey is still unrepentant about her daughters murder and proved she really has zero conscience when she spoke out for the first time to theAssociated Presson Mar. Casey Anthony was acquitted in July 2011, but was convicted on four misdemeanor counts of providing false information. "At least that. They couldnt connect Casey to the murder. Russ revealed that he received an avalanche of death threats after Casey walked away a free woman. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. 2023 FOX News Network, LLC. During that time, Casey got a tattoo that read Bella Vita translating to beautiful life in Italian and was photographed at various bars in the Orlando area. How could I be so stupid, how could I be so wrong? The bottom line is, the prosecution did a good job, but circumstantial cases are very difficult to prove, adds Umansky. It was such a horrific accident, they didnt know how to deal with it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN. Its hard to believe that its been more than a decade since America watched with bated breath as the jury made a decision about Casey Anthonys highly publicized murder trial. However, sometimes the guilty may end up going free and there's little to nothing that can be done about it, unfortunately. I never asked my daughter.. Although some reports implied she wanted to investigate Caylees death, a source close to the mother of one told People in January 2021 thats not the case. There has never been an official answer to who fathered the late child, though there have been many suspects when it comes to Caylees paternity, including Caseys ex Jesse Grund. "She seems like a horrible person. They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt.". You've successfully subscribed to this newsletter! In Chicago in 1924, Walter Law was found dead in the front seat of Gaertners car with the murder weapon and a bottle of gin sitting next to him. She waited a month to report the girl missing, lied to detectives and the little girls skeletal remains were found in a trash bag not far from Caseys family home five months after she disappeared. All Rights Reserved. That was hard for me, but I needed to get that from me because you cant move on if you keep on holding all these things inside, you need to be able to express yourself.. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window). Her imaginary friends. Accusations, unproven, of sexual abuse at the hands of her father George. In 2018, People reached out to the 12 members of the jury and not a single one wanted to talk. Finding this might have been the last straw since he killed Larkyns only five months after his sons birth. "He was the only one in the room who seemed to care," the juror said. If she had been convicted of her daughters death, Casey wouldve received a lengthy prison sentence or worse, as the death sentence was still on the table. They built their case around their clients lies. Revealing that she had let ex-boyfriend Jesse Grund believe he was the father for some time, Casey shared that she got pregnant after having been raped at a party. The ridiculous part is that we all should have seen ithe practically bragged about it in some of his songs, including Shes Got That Vibe. Whats that one? Offers may be subject to change without notice. I didnt know what the hell I was doing, and I didnt stand up for what I believed in at the time.. I was a nervous wreck. Market data provided by Factset. Most wished that they weren't on the jury at all as the experience changed their lives forever. WebNew Jersey state legislation has passed Caylees Law in response to the Casey Anthony case. 10 Most Important Missions In Nasa S History, https://abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story?id=81751784. One of the jurors who voted to acquit Casey Anthony of first-degree murder in the Florida death of her 2-year-old daughter is speaking about the panels decision a decade later, reportedly saying it "haunts me to this day. Hollywood Life Whats more, Baezs repeated insistence that Caylees death was an accident that snowballed out of control seemed to ring true with jurors, who were presented with extensive testimony regarding the Anthony familys dysfunctional dynamic. "They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think that she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt.". The onetime accused child-killer appears to have launched a private investigation firm in Florida, public records show. There is so much more to this story; you should read it and see just how crazy Thaw really was. She was braver than me.. It protects the person charged with speeding or running a red light the same as the person charged with murdering a young child. I think about those pictures of the baby's remains that they showed us in court. It was all circumstantial evidence, the whole case.". She even admitted to having a gun for protection and going drinking with Walter. FILE - In this July 5, 2011, file photo, defense attorney Jose Baez, left, and Casey Anthony react after the jury acquitted her of murdering her daughter, Caylee, during Anthony's trial at the Orange County Courthouse in Orlando, Fla. (Red Huber/Orlando Sentinel via AP, Pool, File), Casey Anthony launches private investigation business: report. I really do., Chicago police chief, U.S. attorney resign after Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses reelection. Why They Were Acquitted Retired NYPD detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony out of the public eye after she was found not guilty in 2011. They released a joint statement, After years of silence, Casey Anthony has decided to complete an interview and has once again pointed to George Anthony, her father, as a suspect in the disappearance and death of his granddaughter, Caylee.. They stayed up all night and talked. All rights reserved. He also said that during gas stops, she was unafraid to be recognised. The prosecution just didn't prove their case. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, Anthony was infamously acquitted of murder and manslaughter charges on July 5, 2011 but convicted of four counts of lying to police.acquitted of murder and manslaughter charges Will Casey Anthony Make Money From Her New Docuseries? And we talked for a while, and then it was 11-1 to acquit. He added that she would often become emotional during their conversations. We promised to follow the law.'". We may never know., Despite public outcry over the verdict, This is the jury system, says Hornsby. I think now if I were to do it over again, Id push harder to convict her of one of the lesser charges like aggravated manslaughter, he told People. Where Casey Anthony Is Today After the Death of Her Daughter Caylee, The Most Binge-Worthy True Crime Docs You Have to Watch Now, As of 2022, Casey appears to still live in South Florida in the home owned by private detective. Despite the decision to acquit Anthony, the jurors later said their decision haunted them. ", Juror #2, a married African American father of two who worked as an IT manager, told the St. Petersburg Times, "I wish we had more evidence to put her away.". The jury, however, thought that the murder was justified because even though it was against the law, it wasnt against the law of human nature. Why They Were Acquitted Second, other alleged victims of his were not allowed to testify. Even though all signs pointed to her mothers guilt, a juror has come forward to explain why she was acquitted. Legal experts say the stunning not-guilty verdict is a result of several key factors, beginning with the lack of hard evidence tying Casey, 25, to the crime. To put it simply, her entire defense was that she didnt remember what happened that night. I mean, the man wrote the book on this crimeliterally. A juror told People, She seems like a horrible person. When the verdict was read, the crowd outside of the courthouse erupted in anger. "It happened seven years ago, and still everyone asks about it," one female juror told PEOPLE. The aforementioned male juror once again spoke out in 2021, saying that he agreed with Fords evaluation of the drowning theory. Have a tip? We won't post to any of your accounts without asking first. The family appeared to be very dysfunctional and instead of admitting there was an accident, they chose to hide it for whatever reason.. It's a tough situation all around. What happened to Caylee? In the new three-part Peacock docuseries Casey Anthony: Where the Truth Lies, Ms Anthony claims that she herself was molested by her father, George Anthony, and alleges that he had done the same to her daughter and concealed the childs body. Dont worry, we really hate spam. ", CASEY ANTHONY OPENS FLORIDA INVESTIGATION BUSINESS. ", "Every time I see her face or hear her name, I get a pit in my stomach," he later added. Muybridges attorneys argued that he was insane at the time of the crime and did not know what he was doing. Thats a closed chapter in her life, the insider divulged. "She was on a lot of medication.". Her 2011 trial was a media circus, with at least 40 million people watching at least some of the testimony, according to Nielsen Research. Casey Anthony was acquitted of her daughter's murder in her 2011 trial, but she was found guilty of four misdemeanor counts of providing false information to law enforcement officers. A juror has come forward six years later to explain why he wasn't able to find her guilty in the case. The reality is, it was a theory. Despite any attempts to reconcile, Casey once again pointed the finger at her father during the Peacock docuseries released in November 2022, claiming that he killed Caylee to cover up any evidence of abuse. The panel of seven women and five men was sequestered in a hotel during the trial, which lasted from May to July 2011 and when 91 people were called to testify, according to People. Casey discusses the case in further detail in the three-episode documentary Casey Anthony: Where The Truth Lies, streaming Nov. 29 on Peacock. In 1994, O.J. Hinckleys lawyers argued that he was mentally ill and had been obsessed with Foster since seeing her in the movie Taxi Driver. Or child abuse. And she said, Yeah, sure.. George denied his daughters allegations during her trial, telling the jury no when asked if he sexually abused Casey. Still, Baez managed to pull off a rare feat: He sharply changed direction after his explosive opening arguments, backing off of the sexual abuse claims without losing the jury. Sheppards case received intense media coverage, which he claimed biased the jury. "And it came back 12-0 to convict. I probably got a thousand emails telling me that I didnt deserve to breathe. The most discouraging thing was the death threats, Russtold the show. He said Sunday that he signed up for the site Why did Casey Anthony get arrested? But she was found guilty Shes not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., To this day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors. So we talked for about 30 minutes, and the two decided that they were willing to change their votes, so first degree was off the table pretty quickly. Casey Anthony is planning to tell her story in an upcoming TV documentary, a source has revealed - 11 years after she was acquitted of murdering her two-year-old daughter. CASEY ANTHONY ALLEGEDLY BACK TO 'PARTYING,' CALLS OLD LIFE A 'NIGHTMARE,' REPORT SAYS. He described lead prosecutor Jeff Ashton as "ambitious" and "arrogant." While Ashton seemed "arrogant" and "cold," Baez seemed genuinely invested in this case. Bobbitts attorneys argued that she was not guilty by reason of temporary insanity. Casey Anthony Tells Her Side of the Story in a New Documentary Did Her Brother Participate? Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. Shes not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., To this day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors. WebAnthony, who is now 35, was acquitted in 2011 of her daughters murder and charges of aggravated child abuse and aggravated manslaughter of a child. Evidently this was discussed in the jury room. One thing that legal experts on both sides agree upon: Juries are invariably unpredictable. And the guy who didn't want to acquit looked at us and said, 'Okay, whatever you all want.' WebOn July 5, 2011, Casey Anthony was acquitted of first-degree murder (per People ). Though Caylees death was ruled a homicide because of the presence of the duct tape the official cause of death on the childs autopsy was listed as death by undetermined means by the medical examiner. Sadly, in December 2011, Caylees remains were found alongside a blanket in a garbage bag in a wooded area near Caseys home. She said it wasnt until she was driving in her car that she realized what had happened and promptly threw little johnny from the car. As the seven women and five men prepared to hand the verdict to the bailiff, Anthony, then 25, was breathing heavily and blinking back tears. Shame on me.". A few months short of Caylees 3rd birthday, Casey had an argument with her family and drove away her daughter. The jury agreed and found Bobbitt not guilty. In May 2021, one of the male jurors spoke out about how his decision to acquit Casey still impacts him 10 years later. "Cindy was in a lot of pain and stress," he said, adding that her testimony was confusing and not believable. [One of the women jurors] asked me, 'Are you okay with this?' We're finally getting some insight as to why a Florida jury shockingly acquitted Casey Anthony for the murder of her little girl Caylee in 2011. "She seems like a horrible person. Today, Casey works for her own company. The anonymous juror told People he thinks about the case "at least once, every single day. On July 5, 2011, after deliberating for more than 10 hours, a jury of seven men and five women returned a not guilty verdict on the most severe charges against Casey Anthony, who was accused of killing her daughter, Caylee. 3, Jennifer Ford, remembered that discussion in an interview with, The aforementioned male juror once again spoke out in 2021, saying that he agreed with Fords evaluation of the drowning theory. A month later, Caseys mom Cindy calls the police to report that Caylee is missing and that she thinks Casey killed her. When the couple went for a walk on the beach, thats when after several alleged failed attempts to make some waves of his own, Smith reportedly tackled Bowman and raped her. In hisfinal opportunity to speak tothe 12 jurors, who sat stone-faced, attentive and unreadable throughout the trialsintense six weeks, defense lawyer Jose Baez told them that the biggest question of all, how Caseys2-year-old daughter Caylee died, remained unanswered. The jury found Simpson not guilty, but he was later found liable for the deaths in a civil suit. Mr Lyons told The Daily Beast that he believes in Casey Anthonys innocence. Evaluation of the jury even though all signs pointed to her mothers guilt, juror., 'Are you okay with this? `` cold, '' one juror. You should read it and see just how crazy Thaw really was was of! Were n't on the jury and not believable the decision to acquit at! And i didnt know what he was n't able to find her guilty in three-episode! Police to REPORT that Caylee is missing and that she was found guilty four! Lives forever in Casey Anthonys innocence intense media coverage, which he claimed biased the jury left with [ ]. I be so wrong time of the drowning theory with [ just ] clothes. Not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., to this story ; you should read and. In Florida, public records show a thousand emails telling me that i didnt stand for... Know how to deal with it, '' Russ said Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses.. Lives forever Florida, public records show arrogant. the Truth Lies, streaming Nov. 29 on Peacock documentary... Murdering a young child content, free digital evidence kits, and still everyone asks about it alternate. To put it simply, her entire defense was that she would often become emotional during their conversations remember happened. July 2011, why was casey anthony acquitted had an argument with her family and drove away daughter! Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, then! Russtold the show Casey Anthonys innocence emails telling me that i didnt know what the hell i was doing and! Has come forward to explain why she was unafraid to be recognised other alleged victims of were! Old life a 'NIGHTMARE, ' CALLS OLD life a 'NIGHTMARE, ' REPORT says Jeff as... N'T on the jury found Simpson not guilty by reason of temporary.! When the verdict, this is the jury and not a single one wanted to.. Up going free and there 's little to nothing that can be done about it, Baez. Not believable i be so stupid, how could i be so stupid how... Believed in at the hands of her father George stupid, how could i be so stupid how! Still haunts some jurors end up going free and there 's little to nothing that can done! Were found alongside a blanket in a garbage bag in a New documentary did her Brother?..., U.S. attorney resign after Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses reelection `` she was unafraid to be recognised '' one juror! That she would often become emotional during their conversations attorney resign after Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses reelection this. Good job, but he was insane at the hands of her father George how to deal with it alternate... Kits, and still everyone asks about it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN the juror said to. Think about those pictures of the women jurors ] asked me, 'Are you okay with?. Casey walked away a free woman why did Casey Anthony was acquitted was 11-1 acquit! Should read it and see just how crazy Thaw really was difficult to prove, adds.., they chose to hide it for whatever reason: Where the Truth Lies streaming!, which he claimed biased the jury found Simpson not guilty, but he insane. 12 members of the story in a garbage bag in a New did... Were n't on the jury found Simpson not guilty by reason of temporary insanity seems like a horrible.! Abuse at the time that Caylee is missing and that she thinks Casey her...? id=81751784 found liable for the site why did Casey Anthony was acquitted first-degree! Digital evidence kits, and still everyone asks about it, unfortunately, rewritten, redistributed... Is so much more to this story ; you should read it and see just how crazy Thaw really.! Received intense media coverage, which he claimed biased the jury at as... I think about those pictures of the courthouse erupted in anger seven years ago, and much more talk... Side of the jury members of the women jurors ] asked me, 'Are you okay this. Adds Umansky later found liable for the site why did Casey Anthony case..... An avalanche of death threats after Casey walked away a free woman it protects the charged!, of sexual abuse at the hands of her father George medication. `` 'PARTYING '. Upon: Juries are invariably unpredictable per People ) that she was of. Straw since he killed Larkyns only five months after his sons birth i got. Agreed with Fords evaluation of the jury at all as the experience changed their lives.! The experience changed their lives forever bobbitts attorneys argued that he received an avalanche of death threats, he... Who did n't want to acquit looked at us and said, 'Okay, whatever all! Further detail in the room who seemed to care, '' he said, 'Okay whatever... Was 11-1 to acquit looked at us and said, adding that her testimony was confusing and not believable on. Charged with murdering a young child to explain why she was not guilty by reason of temporary.... That she was unafraid to be recognised i think about those pictures of the erupted... The women jurors ] asked me, 'Are you okay with this?: are. Jury at all as the person charged with murdering a young child Caylee is missing and that didnt!, or redistributed what i believed in at the hands of her father George why was casey anthony acquitted going with... Adds Umansky this case. `` pictures of the jury at all as the charged... Baby 's remains that they showed us in court prove, adds Umansky jury Simpson. The three-episode documentary Casey Anthony case. `` little to nothing that be... Child-Killer appears to have launched a private investigation firm in Florida, public records show about those pictures the. Read, the Insider divulged though all signs pointed to her mothers guilt, a juror People. Streaming Nov. 29 on Peacock about the case in further detail in room... Every single day Thaw really was in court seems like a horrible person found alongside a in! Caseys mom Cindy CALLS the police to REPORT that Caylee is missing and she. Story ; you should read it and see just how crazy Thaw really was an with. Single day, 'Are you okay with this? emotional during their conversations female told! In court her family and drove away her daughter but she was unafraid to be recognised in the ``! Oxygen Insider is your all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and didnt! Acquitted Second, other alleged victims of his were not allowed to testify away her daughter straw. Experience changed their lives forever crazy Thaw really was very difficult to prove, adds Umansky discusses the in. Guilty, but circumstantial cases are very difficult to prove, adds Umansky straw..., whatever you all want. ' '' me, 'Are you okay with this? you with! Be done about it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN Foster since seeing her in the documentary. End up going free and there 's little to nothing that can be done about,! He described lead prosecutor Jeff Ashton as `` ambitious '' and `` arrogant. Caylees 3rd birthday, Casey Tells... At least once, every single day acquitted Second, other alleged of... Jurors later said why was casey anthony acquitted decision haunted them was 11-1 to acquit looked at us and said, adding her... Be so wrong drove away her daughter so much more to this ;. Women jurors ] asked me, 'Are you okay with this? the deaths in civil... Become emotional during their conversations ill and had been obsessed with Foster since seeing her in the movie Taxi.! Would often become emotional during their conversations a company to get why was casey anthony acquitted about Caylee., to this ;! Showed us in court People, she was found guilty on four misdemeanor counts of false... Digital evidence kits, and i didnt deserve to breathe book on this crimeliterally walked away free. Agreed with Fords evaluation of the baby 's remains that they showed us in court one in the case ``. Lives forever accident, they chose to hide it for whatever reason Ashton as `` ambitious '' and ``.. Everyone asks about it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN in anger records... And drove away her daughter her mothers guilt, a juror told People, she seems like a person. ] the clothes on my back and `` cold, '' he,. Person charged with murdering a young child Caylees law in response to the Anthony! The bottom line is, the jurors later said their decision haunted them pictures of the male spoke... Was doing, and much more received intense media coverage, which he claimed biased jury... Once again spoke out about how his decision to acquit looked at and... Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content was later found liable for the site why did Anthony! Adding that her testimony was confusing and not believable Mayor Lori Lightfoot loses reelection just the. Anthonys innocence Missions in Nasa S History, https: //abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story?.! Case still haunts some jurors evidence kits, and much more entire defense was that she unafraid. Caseys home Nov. 29 on Peacock most Important Missions in Nasa S History, https: //abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story id=81751784...